Judge Milan Smith may not have the final word on California's controversial DNA collection law.
The Ninth Circuit on Wednesday announced that Haskell v. Harris — the challenge to Prop 69's felony DNA swab law — will go en banc. Earlier this year, a split panel led by Smith found the measure that requires swabbing all felony arrestees comported with the Fourth Amendment. That conflicted with a state court of appeal opinion from 2011, and drew a lengthy dissent from his liberal colleague, Judge William Fletcher.
"We have never allowed the compulsory taking of DNA samples from mere arrestees," Fletcher's dissent said. "We should not begin now." A visiting senior judge from Tennessee, James Dale Todd, was the swing vote.
The Ninth Circuit has posted key filings in the case here.
Like the 9th cir is going to change reality! The OC DA Office overcharges (what no) then offers a plea to misdeameanors that includes a DNA SAMPLE. Think thats bad (state bar where are you) the OCSD arrest individuals for felonies then take a DNA sample at IRC and later (within 48hrs) OCDA drops to charges to misdeameors which are accepted in pleas. Nice gig right? Like brother and sister sleeping together and not acknowledging its wrong.
Posted by: the kat | July 26, 2012 at 11:24 AM
Adidas Running Shoes presents all the possible features of this type of shoe from the materials it is made with, to the technologies that make it a top quality running shoe.
Posted by: Adidas Original Shoes | August 06, 2012 at 11:42 PM
Grazie per aver scritto questo. Mi sento come se io so molto di più su questo che ho fatto prima. Il tuo blog veramente portato alcune cose alla luce che non avrei mai pensato prima di leggerlo. Si dovrebbe continuare questa, Im maggior parte delle persone sarebbe d'accordo sicuro youve ha ottenuto un dono.
Posted by: supra skytop | August 13, 2012 at 01:32 AM
Me ei ole kunagi lubatud kohustuslik võtta DNA proove vaid vahialuste, Adidas jooksvate kingad on kõik võimalik funktsioone seda tüüpi kinga materjalidest ta on tehtud, et tehnoloogiad, mis muudavad tippkvaliteediga töötab kinga.
Posted by: maillot basket | August 14, 2012 at 02:47 AM
Hey there! A e dini nëse ata bëjnë ndonjë plugins për të mbrojtur kundër hacker? Unë jam kinda paranojake për humbjen e gjithçka unë kam punuar shumë për. Çdo këshilla? Hey there! A e dini nëse ata bëjnë ndonjë plugins për të mbrojtur kundër hacker? Unë jam kinda paranojake për humbjen e gjithçka unë kam punuar shumë për. Çdo këshilla?
Posted by: chaussures supra skytop | August 30, 2012 at 02:02 AM
I can't help but seeing mandatory DNA swabbing as being an affront on civil liberty. Forget the fourth amendment - what about the first one!
Posted by: Vancouver Personal Injury Lawyer | September 11, 2012 at 12:49 PM
Hi! Lief vir jou lees van jou blogs. Groot energie! Ek het net begin blog myself en aan my lys bygevoeg. Hoop jy sal check out my blog as jy kan! Hou aan met die goeie werk!
Posted by: monster power beats | September 13, 2012 at 02:09 AM
colorful trees on a knot in the shape of the fruit of hundreds of babies. Are the color pink,Nose, eyes clear, fine-grained skin. Turned boy body. Cute little penis is like a cob of redPeanuts.
Posted by: Sparkle Uggs | November 01, 2012 at 02:07 AM
After a few minutes you will begin to feel it working... it feels like a warm tingling sensation.
Posted by: african mango diet | November 05, 2012 at 05:24 PM
Accuracy, verifiability, and accountability of an applicant’s data are also major concerns for managers whose organizations are using e-recruiting systems.
Posted by: specialist recruitment agencies brisbane | November 11, 2012 at 05:15 PM
adversity reveals genius; fortune conceals it http://www.mulberrybagstoreuk.com
Posted by: mulberry handbags | November 14, 2012 at 11:44 PM